Mutual funds and ETFs are both great investment options. But one may be better for you depending on your investment style. Here's how to choose which you should invest in.

If you’re trying to figure out how to get started investing, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. There are many investments to choose from. You can buy stocks, bonds, exchange-traded funds, mutual funds, precious metals, real estate investment trusts, and more.

Two popular options are very similar but do have some major differences. These two are exchange-traded funds and mutual funds.

One of the main questions you might be wondering is what’s the difference between a mutual fund and an exchange-traded fund (ETF)?

Here’s what you need to know.

What is a mutual fund?

Mutual funds are run by asset managers that work at large companies like Vanguard and Fidelity. Each mutual fund has a goal to invest in particular assets. When you buy a mutual fund, you’re essentially investing in whatever the mutual fund invests in.

They typically have minimum investment requirements

Many mutual funds have a minimum initial investment required to buy into the fund. Some funds may not have minimums while other funds could have a minimum of $10,000 or more. These high minimum funds can be a big barrier to investing for those just getting started. However, once you own a mutual fund, you can usually buy fractional shares.

They can offer active or passive investing

Mutual funds can practice active or passive investing strategies. Actively managed mutual funds try to beat the market by trading stocks and other investments based on a set strategy.

Passively managed mutual funds instead set an investment strategy and don’t try to time the market. Many passively managed mutual funds are known as index funds that aim to track a particular index such as the S&P 500.

Mutual funds have management fees

When you buy a mutual fund, you’re buying it from the company that manages it, not another investor. Mutual funds usually charge higher expense ratios because they require more management on the asset manager’s part, especially for actively managed funds.

Mutual funds can also require you to hold the fund for a certain time period or pay an early withdrawal penalty. These penalties usually exist to prevent frequent trading which may increase the costs the funds incur.

Who should invest in mutual funds?

Those who don’t care to pick their own stocks and bonds

Investing in a mutual fund can be a great choice if you don’t like picking individual stocks and bonds. Since mutual funds only update their price at the end of each business day, investors that don’t care for the fluctuation in price throughout the day may be better suited to a mutual fund. 

Those who want to actively manage their funds

Additionally, those looking for more active management of investments to try to maximize gains will likely find mutual funds preferential to exchange-traded funds.

As always, you should consult with a financial professional such as a Certified Financial Planner or another financial advisor to help determine if a mutual fund is suitable for your investing goals.

Where to invest in mutual funds

Investing in mutual funds can be free or require a transaction fee depending on your brokerage firm and which mutual fund you invest in.

Here are a few examples of costs:

E*TRADE

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - E*TRADE Logo

In total, E*TRADE offers over 9,000 mutual funds to purchase. E*TRADE offers over 4,400 no load and no transaction fee funds that are free to trade. There is an early redemption fee for the no load and no transaction fee funds of $49.99.

They also offer transaction fee funds which cost $19.99 per trade.

Vanguard

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Vanguard Logo

Vanguard’s 140+ mutual funds don’t charge transaction fees, but some of them may charge purchase and redemption fees which are usually a percentage of your purchase price. 

Vanguard offers over 3,000 non-Vanguard mutual funds with no transaction fees when you trade online as long as you don’t redeem them within 60 calendar days of the most recent purchase’s trade date. If you do, there is a $50 early redemption fee on these funds. 

There are also over 6,000 non-Vanguard mutual funds that are available with transaction fees that go as high as $20 per trade for online trades and $50 per trade for phone trades.

Fidelity

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Fidelity Logo

In total, Fidelity offers access to over 10,000 mutual funds from hundreds of mutual fund companies. Fidelity offers its own mutual funds which do not charge a transaction fee.

They also offer no transaction fee funds that aren’t Fidelity funds. These have no purchase transaction fees. Redemption transaction fees are $49.95, but only if the mutual fund is held less than 60 days.

Most other non-Fidelity mutual funds that charge transaction fees are $49.95 per purchase and $0 per redemption. That said, certain funds have a transaction fee of $75.

As with Vanguard, certain funds may charge other non-transaction fees including purchase or redemption fees.

What is an ETF?

An exchange-traded fund, or ETF for short, is like a mutual fund in some ways, but very different in others.

ETFs are traded on an exchange

Rather than reprice at the end of every day, ETFs are actually traded live on an exchange. Instead of buying from the mutual fund company, ETF transactions are made between one investor that sells their shares and another that buys the shares. You can buy or sell throughout the day rather than just at the end of each day.

No minimum investment requirements

When you buy ETFs, you can buy a single share for the share price. You don’t have to make a minimum investment like some mutual funds require. This can make investing much easier when you’re first getting started. Some investing platforms may also offer fractional ETF share investing.

ETFs track indexes for the most part. That means they aren’t actively managed or trying to beat the market. Instead, they aim to match an index’s performance, such as the Dow Jones Industrial Average or S&P 500.

The cost of ETFs are typically cheaper than mutual funds

Due to the fact that there is less involved in managing an ETF, the costs are typically lower than mutual funds. 

The way ETFs work also reduces the amount of buying and selling that a manager has to do within a fund while managing it. This may reduce the tax impacts by not having as many gains or losses to distribute compared mutual funds.

Who should invest in ETFs?

If you want to invest in a fund that tracks an index, an ETF might offer a lower cost option. You may also prefer ETFs if you hold your funds in a taxable investment account and want to minimize the distributions of taxable gains and losses before you decide to sell your assets.

Those that want to actively trade throughout the day will prefer ETFs as you can make trades in real-time versus once per day.

Where to invest in ETFs

Each brokerage typically offers the ability to invest in their own ETFs. Many brokerages allow you to invest in other ETFs, too. However, they may charge a fee for this service.

E*TRADE

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - E*TRADE Logo

E*TRADE currently offers 250+ ETFs that you can buy or sell without paying brokerage commissions. There are restrictions, such as a potential short-term trading fee of $15.99 to $19.99 on sales of participating ETFs held less than 30 days. Other potential fees may apply as well.

If you want to buy an ETF that isn’t commission free, you’ll have to pay $6.95 per trade. If you make 30+ trades per quarter, the fee is reduced to $4.95 per trade.

Vanguard

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Vanguard Logo

If you buy one of Vanguard’s 75+ ETFs in your Vanguard brokerage account, you won’t pay a commission. That said, there may be account service fees if you don’t sign up for electronic delivery of your account documents. Other fees may also apply.

Vanguard does provide commission free trading on around 1,800 other ETFs, but only if you make the purchase online. Buying these other ETFs will cost up to $25 per trade over the phone depending on the dollar amount of assets you have invested at Vanguard. 

Fidelity

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Fidelity Logo

Fidelity offers 28 Fidelity ETFs and 329 commission-free iShares ETFs you can buy or sell without paying a fee. Other fees may apply. ETFs from other companies cost just $4.95 for US equity trades.

Betterment

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Betterment

Betterment doesn’t charge trading fees, but they do charge a 0.25% to 0.40% annual fee based on your account balance.

Betterment offers a decent selection of stock and bond ETFs to help properly diversify your portfolio.

Robinhood

Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs - Robinhood

With Robinhood, you can invest in over 5,000 stocks and most U.S. exchange-traded funds in real-time. The best part is Robinhood allows you to trade ETFs (and stocks) for free. SEC & FINRA fees may apply, though.

You can invest any amount with Robinhood too and you can customize your portfolio with different companies and funds based on your preferred level of risk.

Summary

While there are differences between mutual funds and ETFs, as well as the brokerages you can use to invest in them, the real key is getting started. 

Pick whichever type of investment and brokerage firm you think will work best for you. If you find out later on that another option is better, you can always sell your investments or switch brokerage firms. You don’t have to limit yourself to just ETFs or just mutual funds. You can invest in both if you’d like.

If you’re still stuck, you may want to consider consulting with a financial advisor to determine what next steps you need to make. They can make a specific financial plan tailored to your situation that you can use to start investing.

Read more

Related Tools

About the author

Total Articles: 67
Lance Cothern is the founder of Money Manifesto, a personal finance blog that helps people to master their money so they can live their ideal life. In addition to blogging, he enjoys spending time at the beach with his wife and son. You can connect with Lance on Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest and Reddit.

Article comments

We invite readers to respond with questions or comments. Comments may be held for moderation and will be published according to our comment policy. Comments are the opinions of their authors; they do not represent the views or opinions of Money Under 30. Comments have not been reviewed or approved by any advertiser, nor are they reviewed, approved, or endorsed by our partners. It is not our partner’s responsibility to ensure all posts or questions are answered.
1 comment
chandra says:

hello, thank you for a very helpful article. i have a question regarding brokerage accounts. i’d like to stick to one account that gives me a full 360 degree view of my portfolio. my preference is not to scatter my investments across multiple accounts and then spend time on collecting data from all three to build a cohesive picture. it is ok to have multiple account as long as i have some way of getting a consolidated view across all of them. is this possible? any tips? thank you!