YNAB Review: Here's What I Learned After One Year of Using You Need a Budget

(Money Under 30 Rating)

Ranking

8/10

You Need a Budget (YNAB) is more than a software program; it’s a lifestyle. Whether your goal is to get out of debt, break the paycheck-to-paycheck cycle, grow your savings accounts, or all of the above, YNAB’s theory is that giving every dollar “a job” can help.

Open Account


Cost

7/10

Ease of use

8/10

Customer service

10/10

Extra content/workshops

10/10



Best for:

 

  • People who tried and failed at other budgeting methods
  • Couples who need help budgeting together
  • Breaking the paycheck-to-paycheck cycle

Editor's Note - You can trust the integrity of our balanced, independent financial advice. We may, however, receive compensation from the issuers of some products mentioned in this article. Opinions are the author's alone. This content has not been provided by, reviewed, approved or endorsed by any advertiser, unless otherwise noted below.

Readers, I have a confession to make: I’ve been a personal finance writer for five years, but my own finances are far from perfect.

Maybe that’s not unusual, like comedians who suffer from depression.

Nonetheless, writing about money in my professional life while mishandling my own finances has been a source of shame. This past year I decided to do something about it.

After trying and failing to get my family’s spending under control with other budgeting methods, I started a free trial with You Need a Budget. Here’s what I learned.

What Is You Need A Budget (YNAB)?

  • Cost: $14.99/month or $99/year (with a 34-day free trial)
  • Link to bank account? Yes
  • Best budgeting features: You can “give every dollar a job”, so ALL of your money will be budgeted

YNAB is a budgeting app/software program that can be used on a regular computer or mobile device. It’s also a lifestyle, as it requires you to take a proactive approach to budgeting. You’ll give every dollar a job and then adjust as needed between paydays/inflows of money.

In my experience, there’s a bit of a learning curve when you first start using YNAB, but it’s totally worth it to keep going. You can even do a budget restart if you need to (I did).

In addition to the app, YNAB is also a financial education company, with tons of useful blog articles and free workshops to help you use the app better and reach your goals.

Pros & Cons of YNAB

Pros

  • Easy to get started — While there are plenty of features to explore, you don’t have to learn everything to set up your account and start budgeting.
  • Subscription renewal reminder — YNAB will email you a whole week or so before your subscription is set to renew.
  • Manual account linking — For people who don’t want to share their account login with budgeting software, YNAB provides a manual option.
  • No advertising — Since you’re paying for YNAB, they don’t use your data to make targeted offers for credit cards and other financial products. Maybe it’s not the biggest deal in the world, but I do find the lack of ads refreshing.

Cons

  • No free version — You have to pay for it if you want to use it past the trial.
  • Learning curve — You can get started right away, but if you want to get the most out of YNAB, you’ll need to spend some time reading or watching workshops.

How Does YNAB Work?

Your YNAB journey begins with a free 34-day trial. I appreciated the fact that they didn’t ask for a credit card at sign-up.

YNAB Review - Sign up

Once you put in your email and create a password, you have to agree to the Terms of Service.

Then you’ll answer some questions about your circumstances and reasons for trying YNAB. And that’s it. You’re all set and ready to start budgeting. Quick and easy.

I Used The YNAB Budgeting Software For A Year: Here’s What I Learned - Start budgeting

The first step is to add a bank account, which can be linked or unlinked. Personally, I linked mine for easy transaction importing, but since YNAB’s approach is all about being proactive, you can manually add a starting balance and each transaction. This is also good for anyone who feels uncomfortable sharing their bank account login information in spite of YNAB’s security measures.

You can add a variety of accounts, for both budgeting and tracking. To be honest, I haven’t found the tracking feature to be that useful (I prefer Mint’s dashboard for watching my retirement account grow). To keep it simple, just start with a checking account. You’ll give it a nickname and enter a starting balance.

You’ll see default budget categories, but you can delete anything that doesn’t apply to you and add categories as needed. For example, I created a “homemaking” category for getting pictures framed, buying holiday decorations, and other expenses related to preserving family memories and making our house feel like a home. 

How Much Does YNAB Cost?

After your 34-day free trial, you’ll have to pay for YNAB if you want to keep using it. Choose between a monthly or annual subscription:

  • $14.99/month
  • $99/year

YNAB Features

There are plenty of free budgeting apps out there. Here’s what sets YNAB apart and, in my opinion, makes it worth paying for.

Working Balance

Whether you link your bank account to YNAB or add transactions manually, you don’t just see your current available balance (as shown in your online or mobile banking app). Instead, YNAB takes your cleared (available) balance and subtracts any transactions you’ve logged (such as a check you wrote) that haven’t hit your bank account yet.

Cleared balance – Uncleared balance = Working balance

This is how much money you actually have. Use your working balance to make spending decisions and you’ll avoid overspending your account before a check or recurring payment is processed.

To Be Budgeted

One of YNAB’s basic rules is to “give every dollar a job.”

The “To Be Budgeted” box at the top of your budget display shows you how much money has come into your account that hasn’t been assigned a job in your budget yet. The goal is to always have TBB at $0.00. This means every cent has been allocated to your regular expenses and priorities. It doesn’t mean that every dollar has been spent.

For example, let’s say you add $100 each to your auto maintenance and vacation categories. That money will remain in your checking account but you won’t spend it because you’re budgeting with YNAB, not making spending decisions based on your available balance.

Setting money aside for both the inevitable (a car repair) as well as the desired (a week at the beach) will keep you from frittering your extra cash away on takeout dinners and other impulse spending that doesn’t reflect your true priorities.

Age of Money

Once you break the paycheck-to-paycheck cycle, you’ll see this indicator go up.

This is one of my favorite features, as it helped me grasp the importance of not spending every cent and building a cushion instead, not just in savings and retirement accounts, but also in my checking account.

Goals

You can set a monthly goal for each of your spending categories. For example, if you want to save $1,000 for a vacation in 10 months, you’d set a monthly goal of $100 to keep yourself on track.

What I found particularly helpful is the “Pay Off by Date” function of goals for credit card accounts. It’s one thing to think, “I’d like to be debt-free by X date,” but is it actually feasible?

With YNAB, you put your balance payoff date into their calculator, which then tells you how much you’d need to pay each month.

You can then decide if that’s reasonable, or if you should make extra money on the side to meet your goal. If not, you can choose a payoff date goal that fits your budget. 

Wallet

To ensure your budget reflects every last cent you bring in and spend, you can add a cash account called “Wallet” to your ledger. Simply manually enter any cash you earn or are gifted, as well as what you spend it on.

This could be especially helpful for people working in hospitality, restaurants, and other professions in which cash tips or wages are paid.

Reports

This feature provides a big-picture view of your spending habits and finances. You can see how much you spent in each category over a certain period of time.

Depending on how many accounts you link for tracking, you can see your total net worth of assets minus debt.

My Experience Using YNAB

One side perk of being a personal finance writer is learning about every new budgeting system, high-interest savings account, spare change investment app, and so on. Once I’d read enthusiastic reviews of YNAB in a few different places, I decided to try it for myself.

Here are the five most important lessons I’ve learned:

1. My available checking account balance has nothing to do with what I can spend in reality

I used to simply check how much money was in our joint account when I wanted to know if I could afford to sign the kids up for a new activity or pay someone to paint our bedroom.

If there was enough cash in there, I’d spend it. A few days or a week later, my husband would ask why I’d spent money on x when y bill was scheduled to come out later in the month.

2. Giving every dollar a job takes the guilt and uncertainty out of spending

The YNAB system actually looks a lot like my father-in-law’s handwritten ledger. He has categories for “next car,” “home repairs,” etc. His actual checking account balance has nothing to do with how much he spends on a dinner out when we visit — that’s dictated by the “Fun Money” category in his ledger.

YNAB essentially digitizes this, helping me see that I shouldn’t spend on home improvement until I’ve saved enough in that category.

Read more: When It’s OK to Spend Money

3. Any charges to your credit cards, including interest and fees, should be in your budget

One of my favorite things about YNAB is how it holds you accountable for credit card spending. If you currently carry a balance, you can set up a payoff goal and YNAB will help you stay on track for the necessary monthly payments.

It also includes all of your card charges in the “transactions to be categorized” ledger. That cured me of the delusion that credit card spending was some magical other part of my family’s budget.

Read more: How to Use a Credit Card Responsibly

4. Everyone should be spending way below their means

By reminding me to set money aside for car repairs, medical bills, and the other “unexpected” expenses that are really just inevitable over the course of a year, YNAB has helped me see how far below my net income I should really be spending.

A separate emergency fund is fine, but I now see how much of a cash cushion I should have in my checking account. Done correctly, YNAB eliminates the need for a separate emergency fund or other type of savings account, unless you want one.

Read more: Emergency Funds: Everything You Need to Know

5. Change doesn’t happen overnight

At least not for me. When I was young and making a lot less money, I cut my spending naturally. My friends were mostly of the Liberal Arts variety, too; we didn’t have money to blow on drinking in bars or eating at expensive restaurants. So, we cooked together and shared large bottles of cheap wine in each other’s apartments.

Somewhere along the way that changed. It’s like we all progressed through “lifestyle creep” at the same pace. Now, my biggest expenses are related to my kids, like the aforementioned preschool/childcare costs. There’s only so much I can do about that without quitting my job or putting my kids in an unlicensed facility.  

However, I’m embracing the “change happens slowly” mantra. After temporarily giving up on YNAB before I returned to it to write this article, I’m making a daily habit of checking my budget and categorizing my spending. I see the change in my attitudes toward money and everyday spending habits. Eventually, that will translate to more dramatic changes in my finances as I pay off debt and amass that cash cushion.

Who Is YNAB Best For?

Overspenders

Using YNAB will make you more aware of how much money you actually have, where it’s going, and what you need to change to stop running out of money before the next paycheck.

Couples

If you’re trying to budget together (as opposed to letting one person manage the money), YNAB can give you a neutral picture of your budget and money. This may help you avoid arguments and other strong emotions many of us have about spending. It can also empower you to make choices together and celebrate as a team when you reach a specific goal.

Anyone Trying to Pay Off Debt

As mentioned earlier, the Goals feature is a useful tool for figuring out how much you need to pay monthly to pay off a balance by a certain date. This replaces the hazy sense of “someday” I’ll be debt-free with “I’ll pay off my student loan by January 2025.”

Anyone Who Likes to Geek Out on Budgeting

In addition to the help it’s given me, YNAB is also fun to use! 

Who Shouldn’t Use YNAB?

I wasn’t always an overspender. When I was 23 and working my first full-time job after college, I made $12/hour and budgeted in a plain little notebook. I still remember the cost of a week’s worth of groceries from Trader Joe’s (about $50-$55).

I had a small student loan (about $7,000) and no credit card debt. I didn’t even have an actual credit card. I was splitting a $1,050/month apartment with a friend and managed to follow my dad’s “Pay yourself first” rule of putting 10% of every paycheck into savings.

The following year I moved to Prague to teach English. I was paid off the books in Czech crowns and budgeted out of my suitcase, where I kept whatever money I happened to have on a given day. Half of my monthly income went to rent, which I paid in cash by leaving my portion in a glass jar on top of the refrigerator.

So while I think everyone could get something out of YNAB, it may not be necessary (or affordable) for someone truly living on a shoestring budget. The less money you have, the more aware of every cent you are, because there’s no room to mess up. At this stage of my life, with a spouse to budget with and two children to support, YNAB helped me get a handle on my complicated finances.

YNAB vs. the Competition

YNAB isn’t the only budgeting software/app. Here are a few alternatives if $14.99/month or $99/year is above your price range.

PocketSmith

I Used The YNAB Budgeting Software For A Year: Here’s What I Learned - Pocketsmith

  • Cost: Free for basic features and paid plans start at $9.95 per month ($7.50 when paid annually)
  • Link to bank accounts? Yes
  • Best budgeting features: A personalized dashboard where you can see all your “financial key metrics” like your net worth and spending activity

PocketSmith helps you build better financial habits through a timeline that includes your past and present behaviors. You can see how far you’ve come, as well as where your finances will likely be months and years into the future. This visualization can help keep you motivated as you budget and save.

With PocketSmith, you can connect to your financial institution to track spending. The budget-setting feature helps you see the impact your spending will have in future years. PocketSmith is a great app, but if you aren’t interested in seeing your finances on a timeline, you may be better off with YNAB.

MoneyPatrol

I Used The YNAB Budgeting Software For A Year: Here’s What I Learned - MoneyPatrol

  • Cost: $59.99 per year (after a 15-day free trial)
  • Link to bank accounts? Yes
  • Best budgeting features: You can set a spending projection for each expense, and since your spending is monitored, the platform will know when you exceed that budget

While MoneyPatrol packs in the usual budgeting and tracking features, what stands out most is its use of data. This technology helps the app gather insights that help you learn how to improve your financial standing.

Although budgeting and insights are part of MoneyPatrol, the app is really geared toward helping you track your spending. In the process, you’ll learn more about your habits so that you can make adjustments in order to reach your goals.

The Bottom Line on YNAB

Since there are plenty of free budgeting apps and tools out there, you may wonder why you should pay for YNAB.

As is often true with personal finance, the answer depends on your temperament and situation. Some people can stick to a new budget or habit without external accountability. For me, the cost is worth it because:

  • I think YNAB offers a superior product to comparable free options.
  • Knowing I’m paying for it encourages me to use it, just like my gym membership.

Read more:

About the author

Elizabeth Spencer
Total Articles: 41
Elizabeth Helen Spencer is a personal finance and travel writer based in the Philadelphia area. She holds an MFA in Creative Writing and still nurses a secret fiction writing habit on the side. When not writing for work or pleasure, she loves to sweat it out in a hot yoga class and find new books to read. Elizabeth lives with her husband and two children and has reached the conclusion that "having it all" is a myth.